Equality before God does not mean that everyone receives the same circumstances on Earth.

It means that no soul is created more valuable, more loved, or destined for greater spiritual worth than another.

Many earthly inequalities are created by human choices and must be confronted, not spiritually justified.

If all souls are equal before God, why is life so unfair?

Marie’s Video Answer

watch in widescreen

Marie’s In-Depth Answer

  • God is impartial. Human society is not.

    Spiritism teaches that all souls share the same spiritual nature, are subject to the same moral laws, and are called toward the same ultimate progress.

    No one is created to be permanently superior or inferior to anyone else.

    Spiritual equality means equal dignity, not identical earthly lives.

  • Equal souls can live very unequal lives

    We enter the world with different bodies, abilities, histories, families, opportunities, and social conditions.

    Some differences may reflect different stages of spiritual experience. But many inequalities are created and maintained by pride, selfishness, discrimination, violence, inherited privilege, and the misuse of freedom.

    These injustices should not be attributed to God.

  • Reincarnation must never become an accusation

    Spiritism places one lifetime within a longer spiritual journey.

    But that larger perspective does not allow us to look at someone’s poverty, illness, exclusion, abuse, or suffering and claim that they deserved it because of another life.

    We rarely know the deeper causes behind another person’s circumstances.

    Reincarnation must never be used to blame someone for their suffering.

  • Earthly advantage is not spiritual superiority

    A person may have wealth, health, education, freedom, or social power without being morally superior to someone who has far less.

    Likewise, hardship is not evidence of spiritual failure.

    The circumstances of one lifetime do not measure the worth of a soul.

  • Equality tells us what injustice requires from us

    Equality before God does not make an unfair world acceptable.

    It explains why unfairness matters.

    Every person we ignore, exploit, diminish, defend, or protect possesses the same spiritual dignity that we do.

    The question is not only why life is unfair. It is what we will do when another person is treated as though their life matters less.

Doctrinal Source | Grounded in The Spirits’ Book by Allan Kardec, Questions 803–824, concerning natural equality, unequal abilities and social conditions, wealth and poverty, equal rights, and the spiritual dignity shared by all souls.

Related Questions

  • Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?

    Explore why suffering does not prove guilt—and why Spiritism refuses to explain every painful experience as deserved or predetermined.

    Explore the answer

  • What Does Justice Mean Beyond Laws and Punishment?

    Explore why justice begins with equal dignity and asks not only who is responsible, but who must be protected and what can be repaired.

    Explore the answer

  • What Is Moral Law, According to Spiritism?

    Explore the principles that connect conscience, justice, responsibility, and the way we choose to treat other people.

    Explore the answer

  • No. Spiritual equality does not mean identical abilities, circumstances, opportunities, or experiences.

    Spiritism teaches that souls may be at different stages of development and may pass through very different earthly conditions. What remains equal is their fundamental spiritual dignity and their ultimate capacity for progress.

    Difference therefore does not automatically mean injustice. Injustice begins when differences are used to deny another person rights, dignity, protection, or opportunity.

    Equality means that no difference in circumstance makes one soul inherently worth more than another.

  • Spiritism distinguishes natural differences from inequalities created or maintained by human beings.

    People may differ in abilities, experience, health, or circumstance. But exploitation, discrimination, extreme privilege, oppression, and preventable deprivation can result from selfishness and the misuse of human freedom.

    Calling those conditions “God’s plan” can turn spiritual belief into an excuse for refusing responsibility.

    Human injustice should be confronted as human injustice, not sanctified as divine intention.

  • Spiritism allows for the possibility that present circumstances belong to a spiritual history larger than one lifetime.

    But we usually do not know that history, and reincarnation should never be used to infer that a person deserved poverty, illness, abuse, discrimination, or tragedy.

    Many forms of suffering also arise from natural conditions, collective systems, and the free choices of other people.

    Reincarnation may broaden the question of justice, but it does not give us permission to blame the person who suffers.

More About This Question