Do we really have free will, or is everything predetermined?

Spiritism does not teach that every event in our lives is fixed in advance.

We are born into conditions we do not completely control, and our freedom is never absolute.

But within those limits, we still participate in what we choose, how we respond, and who we become.

Marie’s Video Answer

watch in widescreen

Marie’s In-Depth Answer

  • Your life is not a finished script

    Free will is real, but it does not exist outside circumstance.

    You enter life with a body, a history, instincts, relationships, social conditions, and consequences already in motion. These can expand or restrict the choices available to you.

    Freedom does not mean beginning life without limits.

  • Some conditions may be chosen, not every event

    According to Spiritism, a Spirit may participate in choosing the general nature of certain trials before birth.

    But this does not mean every encounter, accident, injustice, or decision has already been written.

    Choosing some conditions is not the same as choosing everything that happens within them.

  • Freedom exists in degrees

    A child does not exercise freedom in the same way as an adult.

    Fear, coercion, illness, ignorance, trauma, or severe social pressure can also reduce a person’s real capacity to choose.

    That is why moral responsibility cannot be measured without considering intention, understanding, and circumstance.

    Freedom is real, but it is not identical for everyone in every situation.

  • Influence is not destiny

    We are shaped by tendencies, habits, circumstances, other people—and, according to Spiritism, spiritual influences.

    But a tendency can be resisted. Help can be accepted. Harm can be interrupted. A different direction may begin with a very small decision.

    What influences us does not automatically determine us.

  • Your response is not meaningless

    Free will does not mean that you control everything that happens to you.

    The past shapes the field on which you act, but it does not write every move. Some conditions cannot be changed, and some consequences were created by other people.

    Yet within those limits, your will still participates in the person you are becoming.

    You may not control the whole field. But your response still matters.

Doctrinal Source | Grounded in The Spirits’ Book by Allan Kardec, Questions 843–872, concerning free will, the limits imposed by circumstance, fatalism, moral responsibility, and the freedom to choose how we respond.

Related Questions

  • Do We Choose Our Life Before We Are Born?

    Explore how some conditions may be prepared before incarnation without turning an entire life into a predetermined script.

    Explore the answer

  • How Do Spirits Influence Human Life Without Taking Away Our Freedom?

    Explore how spiritual influence may affect thoughts and impulses without removing personal choice or responsibility.

    Explore the answer

  • How Do I Become a Better Person?

    Explore how self-awareness, repeated choices, and the effort to change gradually shape who we become.

    Explore the answer

  • Free will does not mean that everyone begins life with the same possibilities.

    We are born into different bodies, families, societies, economic conditions, abilities, and circumstances. Some of those conditions may severely restrict the choices realistically available to a person.

    Spiritism therefore cannot judge responsibility only by outward results. Intention, understanding, opportunity, and the actual freedom someone possessed all matter.

    Equality of spiritual value does not mean equality of earthly circumstances or opportunity.

  • Not in the sense that every event and decision has been fixed in advance.

    Spiritism allows that some broad circumstances or trials may be connected with a Spirit’s incarnation, but what happens within them remains affected by personal choices, the freedom of others, and events that were not individually predetermined.

    Fatalism would make moral responsibility meaningless.

    A life may contain prepared conditions without becoming a script whose ending has already been written.

  • Yes. Choices can create habits, obligations, consequences, and circumstances that make some future options easier and others harder.

    But a limitation is not always the same as complete determination. A habit can be challenged, help can be sought, harm can be repaired, and a new direction can begin even when the consequences of the past cannot simply be erased.

    The past can narrow the field of choice without removing every possibility of choosing differently.

More About This Question