Wanting to change is not always the same as being ready to change. We may sincerely dislike a pattern while still finding comfort, pleasure, or familiarity in repeating it.
Spiritism teaches that change becomes possible through will, effort, and repeated choices. Progress rarely happens in one decision; it grows each time we recognize an old tendency and choose differently.
Why Do I Want to Change but Keep Doing the Same Thing?
Marie’s Answer
You can sincerely want to change and still repeat the same behavior.
That does not necessarily mean your desire to change is false. It means that understanding what is wrong and becoming capable of acting differently are not always the same thing.
A habit repeated many times becomes easier to repeat. A reaction you have followed for years can begin to feel automatic. And sometimes, even when you dislike the consequences, some part of you still finds comfort, pleasure, protection, or familiarity in the pattern.
This is why saying “I want to change” is only the beginning.
Change asks something more of you: to notice the moment when the old response appears and create enough space to choose another one.
At first, that space may be very small.
You may fail many times. You may recognize the pattern only after repeating it. But recognition itself matters, because what was once unconscious has begun to enter your awareness.
Spiritism places great importance on will. But will is not merely declaring what you want. It becomes real through action.
Every time you resist an old tendency, even imperfectly, you weaken its authority over you. Every time you repeat a better choice, you make that choice a little easier to make again.
And you are not required to do this entirely alone. Good spirits may encourage, strengthen, and inspire you—but they cannot choose in your place. Their help supports your freedom; it does not replace it. The Spirits’ Book explicitly connects sincere prayer with assistance from good spirits in overcoming harmful passions.
Change is therefore rarely a single victory.
It is a gradual transfer of authority—from the tendency that once governed you to the spirit that is learning to govern itself.
You may still struggle with what you thought you had overcome.
What matters is whether, little by little, it commands you less.
Doctrinal Source | Grounded in The Spirits’ Book by Allan Kardec, especially Questions 909–912, concerning will, harmful tendencies, spiritual assistance, and the effort to overcome the predominance of material impulses.
Related Questions About Change
Can I Really Overcome My Worst Tendencies?
1
Yes. Spiritism teaches that harmful tendencies are not permanent definitions of who you are. They may be deeply rooted and difficult to change, but repeated effort and conscious choices can gradually weaken their influence.
Progress does not require you to stop struggling immediately. A tendency may return even after you thought you had overcome it. What matters is whether you recognize it sooner, resist it more often, and allow it to govern fewer of your decisions. Real change is often gradual, but that does not make it less real.
Can Good Spirits Help Me Overcome My Lower Impulses?
2
Yes, but they cannot do the work in your place. Spiritism teaches that good spirits can encourage, inspire, and strengthen us when we sincerely ask for help, especially when we are trying to resist harmful tendencies.
Their influence does not remove temptation or override our freedom. You still have to recognize the impulse and make the choice. Spiritual help supports your will rather than replacing it. The more sincerely you participate in your own change, the more meaningful that help can become.
What Does It Mean for Spirit to Overcome Matter?
3
It does not mean rejecting the body, emotions, or material life. It means that your impulses and immediate desires gradually lose the power to determine your choices automatically.
As the spirit progresses, conscience, reason, and moral intention increasingly guide behavior. You can still experience desire, anger, fear, or temptation without being compelled to obey them. To overcome matter is therefore not to become less human, but to become more capable of choosing what you do with everything you experience.
Continue Exploring
-
Explore how Spiritism understands spiritual influence—and why outside influences can affect our thoughts and impulses without removing our responsibility for what we choose.
-
Discover how Spiritism reconciles personal freedom with circumstances, tendencies, and influences that can make some choices easier or harder than others.
-
Explore how personal growth, responsibility, and the ability to change direction are part of a larger purpose that is built through the choices you make.